Church Insurance in Mount Vernon, Ohio

Welcome to Dumbaugh Insurance! We are an Ohio insurance agency with offices in Mount Vernon, Fredericktown, Delaware, and Steubenville. We’ve been helping protect churches across Ohio since 1939.

Give us a quick call today at (740) 397-1234.

Why Do I Need a Church Insurance Policy?

There are many reasons you need to protect your church with an insurance policy:

The reality is today’s church is at a higher risk than ever for legal action.

With Dumbaugh Insurance, you never have to wonder whether you have sufficient coverage or not. Our independent insurance agency takes the worry out of your hands.

We’ve partnered with Mennonite Mutual and we have a genuine interest in finding the right solutions for you and your church.

Why Choose Dumbaugh Insurance in Mount Vernon, Ohio?

Our main job is to make your church insurance as simple and worry-free as possible.

Our carefully assembled team of professionals has diverse, in-depth knowledge and experience in all areas of personal and business insurance and employee benefits.

Give one of our agents a call today to request a quote.

Our Church Insurance Services

  • Free Onsite Review – A professional from Mennonite Mutual & Dumbaugh Insurance will do a thorough inspection of your building and property, as well as your operations, practices, and current policy.
  • Thermal Imaging of Buildings – Our review includes utilizing a thermal imaging camera that will identify possible areas of moisture infiltration or electrical hazards.
  • Background Screening Program
  • Firearm/Security Assistance – Ohio law does not allow concealed carry permit holders to carry in churches. However, churches may give individuals permission to do so. We can help with additional training for church-specific security scenarios.
  • Youth Protection Assistance
  • Free Boiler Inspection – We reimburse the boiler inspection fees for state-mandated inspections.
  • Personal Service – We are a local, family-run agency and look forward to serving you and your ministry.
  • A+ Rated Insurance Company

Our Church Insurance Quote Process

We strive to make the process easy:

  • Basic information is taken down and transferred to Mennonite Mutual.
  • A Mennonite Mutual representative will contact you to set up a day and time to meet at your church.
  • A Mennonite Mutual representative and a Dumbaugh Insurance representative will meet you at your church and go through the building, as well as your current policy and procedures to make sure we provide all the coverages necessary.
  • 1-2 weeks later we receive a customized quote for your church and send a proposal over.
  • Let us help you cut your insurance costs and start saving money without forfeiting coverages.

Let Us Help You Find Church Insurance Coverage

All four offices—located in Mount Vernon, Fredericktown, Delaware, and Steubenville—insure churches across the state of Ohio.

Contact us today or click GET STARTED below to submit one of our quick online quote forms, and find out what it’s like to do business with an independent agency that truly cares about its clients.


Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at Dumbaugh Insurance is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

Call Email Claims Payments