Referral Partners

Thank you for trusting us with your referrals!  We appreciate each and every referral and go out of our way to find the best insurance option for each client, as quickly as possible.  Below is a summary of some of our markets, companies, active states, and specialized insurance markets we can help with.

Personal Insurance Companies

  • Nationwide
  • Progressive
  • Safeco (Liberty Mutual)
  • Westfield
  • Cincinnati
  • Frankenmuth Mutual
  • Keystone National
  • Openly
  • Hippo
  • Lemonade
  • Hagerty

Commercial Insurance Companies

We write all types of commercial insurance and through a variety of national and regional insurance companies.

  • Liberty Mutual
  • Cincinnati
  • Westfield
  • Keystone National
  • NSI/West Bend
  • Frankenmuth Mutual
  • Progressive
  • Mennonite Mutual
  • Philadelphia
  • Nationwide
  • CNA
  • Cowbell Cyber
  • Next

Active States

  • OH
  • IN
  • MI
  • KY
  • PA
  • WV
  • TN
  • GA
  • SC
  • AZ
  • CO

Commercial Niche Markets

We specialize in several insurance markets therefore we can match our expertise with a select group of insurance companies to offer preferred insurance solutions.

  • Rentals/Apartments/Habitational – Keystone National, Honeycomb
  • Churches – Mennonite Mutual
  • Farm – Westfield, Nationwide, & Mennonite Mutual
  • Dentists – Cincinnati
  • Accounting Firms – Cincinnati
  • Non-Profits/Social Services – Cincinnati, Philadelphia, & West Bend
  • Senior Care (Nursing Homes, Assisted Living, etc)
  • Cyber – Cowbell Cyber

Last but not least please let us know if we can answer any questions or do anything to help, and feel free to reach out to us whichever way works best for you.

  • Call or text us at 1-740-397-1234
  • Email us at
  • Thank you again for your referrals!

    Request Your Proposal Here

    Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at Dumbaugh Insurance is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

    Call Email Claims Payments